Then, the bell chimed again.
A man walked in. He was tall, wearing a heavy trench coat that seemed out of place for the weather. He walked straight to Mark’s table and sat down without saying a word.
Mark looked like he was about to faint. I leaned in, trying to catch their conversation over the hiss of the espresso machine.
“Do you have it?” the stranger asked. His voice was a low, guttural rasp.
“I left her,” Mark whispered, his voice cracking. “I did exactly what you said. I broke her heart. I’m out. Now, please… let my sister go.”
My breath hitched. My husband hadn’t left me because he stopped loving me. He hadn’t left me for another woman. He had left me because he was being extorted.
The contact “LOVE” wasn’t a mistress. As I looked closer at the stranger, I realized he was holding a phone. On the screen was a live feed of a basement—and sitting in a chair, bound and gagged, was Mark’s younger sister, Sarah, who had gone “traveling” three weeks ago.
The stranger leaned forward, his voice dropping to a hiss. “You did well, Mark. But the divorce was just the beginning. If you want her to stay alive, you’re going to have to do something much harder.”
The stranger looked toward the corner booth—straight at me. He smiled, a slow, predatory grin.
“You were followed,” the stranger said.
Mark turned around, his eyes wide with horror as they met mine. In that second, I realized that by coming here, I hadn’t solved the mystery. I had just become the next piece of the lever they were using to break him.