“Who is she?” I whispered.
“My first wife,” he choked out. “The one I told you died in the accident before we met. She didn’t die, Sarah. We just… we couldn’t make it work. But she got pregnant right as the divorce was finalized. I didn’t find out until three years ago.”
For three years, he had been living two lives. He wasn’t at the gym; he was at a small house two towns over, playing “Daddy” to children I didn’t know existed, with a woman he had told me was a ghost.
The “Can’t wait to see you” text wasn’t a seductive invitation; it was a mother telling a father that his children were waiting for him. But the betrayal felt even deeper. He hadn’t just cheated on our marriage; he had cheated me out of the truth of who he was.
“I didn’t know how to tell you,” he sobbed, sinking to the floor. “I knew you’d leave if you knew I had a whole other family.”
I looked at the phone, then at the man I thought I knew for over a decade. The laundry was still in the dryer, warm and soft, but the home we built was cold.
“You’re right,” I said, standing up and reaching for my car keys. “I am leaving.”